West Ham United 1-1 Manchester City: Premier League – as it happened

Comments · 26 Views

No word from David Moyes again, but never mind that, because Jona.....t 12.30pm.

No word from David Moyes again, but never mind that, because Jonathan Liew’s match report has landed. It’s merely a click away. Thanks for reading this MBM!

Pep’s verdict. “We start really good. After we conceded a goal, we struggled to find it. In the second half we were much better. They defended so deep. But we had chances at the end. We move forward. We didn’t play bad except in the last ten minutes of the first half. We had the chances but we didn’t do it.” He also reports that Sergio Aguero is injured with a new, unspecified problem.

Phil Foden reflects. “We would have liked to get the three points today. We played well and controlled most of the game, so we’re disappointed not to get the win. But we’re not a team to sulk a lot, so we’ll work to improve. On another day, Raz and Riyad finish their chances. We need to work on finishing more chances, and we’ll be OK.”

Declan Rice speaks. “It’s a great point. We’ve been in fantastic form. In the first half we were excellent, they only had one shot on target and we nullified their main players. Mic scored a great goal. In the second half, it’s something we need to work on, we started a bit sloppy after sitting down at half time. Phil scored a great goal and we had to dig in. They’re a possession-based team and we’re trying to cover our lines, and it doesn’t help when they bring De Bruyne on with 20 minutes to go! I thought the lads were excellent. It shows we’re building something, the manager’s been brilliant. We’ve found a formation that suits our players, and that’s what West Ham fans expect.”

That leaves both teams in mid-table on eight points. West Ham are tenth, City 11th. The Hammers deserved their point. City were dominant, but the resilient hosts hassled them into missing a series of good chances. Also, Michail Antonio’s splendid first-half overhead kick deserved some reward. It’s a much better point for them than City, who will be slightly concerned by the ground they’ve already given up in the title race. “Problem with City in big games and defining moments is that there second striker so to speak is Sterling, and he won’t get you that goal if he has time to think about it,” argues Paul Fitzgerald.


FULL TIME: West Ham United 1-1 Manchester City

Gundogan slips Mahrez into the box down the left. He opens his body for a shot. Fabianski turns round the post. Nothing comes of the corner, and after a dogged second-half defensive display, West Ham have their hard-earned point! City drop two precious ones.

90 min +2: City still pressing. West Ham still holding out.

90 min +1: Balbuena, of all people, chases a loose ball up the West Ham right. He slides in on Dias and is booked for his trouble. A better-timed challenge, though, and he’d have been free down the wing! I strongly suspect David Moyes would rather he stayed back, but there it is.

90 min: There will be three additional minutes. Can City find a winner and claim all three points?

89 min: The dreadful Yarmolenko gifts possession to Sterling, who dribbles down the left in acres. He hesitates as he reaches the box, though, and is eventually crowded out by Ogbonna and Balbuena.

88 min: Mahrez dribbles clear down the right but strangely runs the ball straight out of play with options in the middle. West Ham suddenly look extremely tired.

87 min: Rodri sends a wild shot miles over the bar from 25 yards. It’s a daft effort, releasing the pressure that had been building on West Ham. On the touchline, Pep spins and waves his arms in the frustrated fashion.

86 min: Now it’s City’s turn to spurn a fine chance! De Bruyne slips Sterling into the box down the inside-left channel. He’s one on one, but slaps straight at Fabianski, who smothers at his feet! Breathless drama here.

West Ham’s goalkeeper Lukasz Fabianski thwarts Manchester City’s Raheem Sterling.
West Ham’s goalkeeper Lukasz Fabianski thwarts Manchester City’s Raheem Sterling. Photograph: Justin Tellis/Pool/AP


84 min: From the corner, West Ham break and Fornals is sent clear! The flag stays down - correctly, as he’d made his run from the halfway line - and he’s one on one with Ederson! But he panics, and in attempting to chip the keeper, merely scoops softly into his arms. What a chance to complete an amazing smash-and-grab!

83 min: City want all three, though, and go again. De Bruyne, deep on the left, shovels a diagonal pass towards Mahrez, who chests down and prepares to shoot from close range. Ogbonna lashes clear just in time. Corner.


82 min: A welcome breather for West Ham as Fornals chases a long ball down the left and draws a clumsy foul from Dias. He takes his sweet time to get up. West Ham load the box. Cresswell takes. Dias clears. But time ticks on, and West Ham are closer to a hard-earned point.

80 min: Ogbonna clatters into Sterling, and this is a free kick in a very dangerous position, 25 yards out, just left of centre. De Bruyne’s eyes light up. He sends a dipper over the wall, towards the top left. But it’s not quite high enough, and Fabianski claims.

79 min: Zinchenko has finally been sent on, by they way. He arrived between those corners, replacing Walker, Cancelo switching flanks.

78 min: Cancelo works his way down the left and crosses low and hard. Balbuena is forced to stick out a leg and nearly turns the ball into his own net. One corner leads to another, which leads to a De Bruyne dribbler that Fabianski claims.

77 min: An almighty tangle of bodies in the West Ham box, De Bruyne, Cancelo and Sterling all pressing hard. Not sure how it didn’t lead to either a shot on goal, or a penalty. But here we are.

76 min: City continue to stroke it around at half pace. West Ham hold their shape.

74 min: City’s tempo has dropped a little. West Ham will be more than happy about that, given the amount of chasing they’ve had to do this afternoon.

72 min: More time and space for Yarmolenko on the right. Once again he over-complicates things when a simple ball inside for Haller was on. Cancelo and Foden combine to strip him of possession. Yarmolenko has been pretty poor since coming on. West Ham miss the livewire Antonio.

71 min: Mahrez and Sterling make a nuisance of themselves on the edge of the West Ham box. The ball breaks left to De Bruyne, who sends a low fizzing ball across the face of goal. Nobody in City black makes a move.

69 min: That’s Bowen’s last act of the afternoon. He’s replaced by Haller. Meanwhile on comes De Bruyne, who takes the place of Bernardo Silva. It’s going to be an interesting final 20 all right.

68 min: A more progressive sequence by West Ham, and Bowen has the chance to shoot from the right-hand edge of the D. He sends his effort screaming over the bar.

66 min: West Ham manage to string a few passes together, but it’s all very timid stuff in the middle of the park, and the move unravels quicksmart when they try to advance into City territory. City are in total control ... and Kevin De Bruyne is preparing to come on. Worrying times for West Ham.

64 min: The corner’s worked back to the excellent Cancelo, who opens his body and sends a curler not too far wide of the top left. You don’t need to be an experienced lip-reader to understand the subsequent effing and jeffing.

63 min: Mahrez spins free in the middle before sending Sterling away down the inside-left channel. Sterling’s probing pass, intended for Foden, is deflected out for a corner.

61 min: Ederson claims with great authority amid a bustling box. That’s a really confident claim. City go up the other end, Walker sending a piledriver goalward from 25 yards. It’s straight into Fabianski’s midriff.

City kepeer Ederson claims the ball.
City kepeer Ederson claims the ball. Photograph: Justin Tallis/Pool/EPA


60 min: This is better, though, as Bowen drives down the inside-right channel to win a corner.

59 min: Mahrez slips Walker away down the right. Walker shanks a woeful cross deep into the stand behind the goal. City continue to dominate. West Ham are yet to react.

57 min: Foden latches onto a simple long ball down the middle and tries to hoick spectacularly home from 30 yards. He doesn’t quite catch it and it’s an easy claim for Fabianski. City are causing West Ham all sorts of problems now. “Is there a more error prone referee in the Premiership than Anthony Taylor?” wonders Ian Burch. “With his indecisiveness and poor decision making he’s the refereeing equivalent of Porridge’s Mr Barrowclough. He pales into comparison with Mike Dean’s Mr Mackay act.”

56 min: Yarmolenko is sent scampering into space down the right. He’s got options in the middle, but overdoes the fancy footwork and eventually falls over, the ball rolling apologetically out for a goal kick.

54 min: Gundogan pings a glorious ball down the inside-left channel for Cancelo, who has sprung the offside trap. He’s clear, but miscontrols and lets the ball squirt out for a goal kick. He puts his head in his hands and screams. What a great chance that was. City have clearly been given the hairdryer treatment at half-time.

53 min: And it’s a double blow for the Hammers, because Antonio has picked up an injury and makes way for Yarmolenko.

GOAL! West Ham United 1-1 Manchester City (Foden 51)

Cancelo has had the beating of Coufal all day, and he zips past him down the left again. His low cross finds Foden on the left-hand corner of the six-yard box with his back to goal. He swivels, sorts his feet, and lashes into the bottom left. What an impact by the sub!

Phil Foden fires home Manchester City’s equaliser.
Phil Foden fires home. Photograph: Justin Tallis /Pool/Getty Images
Manchester City’s Phil Foden is congratulated by Riyad Mahrez after putting City back on level terms.
Manchester City’s Phil Foden is congratulated by Riyad Mahrez after putting City back on level terms. Photograph: Paul Childs/Reuters


51 min: Coufal is booked for leaving one on Cancelo. He has the good grace to give the ref a nod of acceptance.

50 min: It’s been all City since the restart. Looks like they might be preparing another change, though, with Zinchenko warming up.

48 min: Rodri has a belt from 25 yards. It’s deflected wide right for a corner. Rice blooters clear. Antonio tries to zip past Walker but the City defender holds firm. Just as well, as Antonio would have been free otherwise.

47 min: Balbuena knocks the corner clear. Dias tries to launch a new phase of attack by working his way down the right, and he’s shoved over by Masuaku, but the referee doesn’t give anything for that either. Very strange.

City get the second half underway. They’ve made a change at the break, replacing Aguero with Foden. They’ve also been yammering at the referee en masse, presumably still going on about the Soucek hand-ball that wasn’t. But they snap into business mode the second the whistle goes, Foden driving down the left and winning a quick corner.

Controversy corner. Replays of the build-up to the goal show the ball hit Soucek on the hip, not the arm. So that one’s out of the way. Let’s replace it with the Garcia challenge on Antonio (25 min). In the opinion of Joe Cole and Joleon Lescott on BT Sport, there was contact before he touched the ball, and it should have been a penalty. The channel’s resident refereeing expert, Peter Walton, then performed an Olympic-standard gymnastic routine, jumping through a series of hoops to explain why the ref wasn’t at least called to the VAR monitor for a second look. “We don’t want them to be forensically analysing the game,” is what comes off the top of his head. This guy’s good.

Half-time entertainment ... and a reminder that when this match is done, Barry Glendenning will be at the helm for MBM coverage of El Clásico.

HALF TIME: West Ham United 1-0 Manchester City

The Hammers lead thanks to Michail Antonio’s marvellous overhead kick. They’ve looked dangerous in attack, while restricting City to speculative efforts. Much to think about for Pep. Plenty of time to put it right, of course. No flipping!

45 min: There will be one added minute.

43 min: Fabianski pumps long. Cancelo takes a heavy touch and allows Bowen to race down the right. That sets West Ham up for a series of speculative shots and crosses. City hold firm, blocking efforts by Masuaku and Soucek, but they’re in panic mode all of a sudden. West Ham’s confidence has ballooned after that slow start.

42 min: Cresswell dinks it down the inside right again, but this time Antonio’s there. He takes down well, but can’t get a shot away, as he’s quickly swarmed by defenders.

41 min: A free kick for West Ham midway into City territory. The hosts line up on the edge of the box. Cresswell takes, and plays a ball down the inside-right channel to nobody. What a waste. But they’ll get another chance, because Fornals has just been barged over in exactly the same place. Take two.

39 min: Cancelo has the beating of Coufal. He drops a shoulder to make space down the left and curls in. Fabianski claims. This match continues to flow freely.

37 min: Masuaku sashays down the left, nearly opening City up. Walker sticks to his guns though and the West Ham wing-back is forced to check back. Cresswell whips into the box instead, but his dangerous-looking cross is deflected, the sting removed, and dribbles back to Ederson.

35 min: Cresswell curls in from the left. Antonio shapes to perform the spectacular again, but Walker reads it well and blocks out for a corner. City deal with the set piece easily enough.

34 min: Garcia channels his inner Beckenbauer, striding up the middle and pearling a low shot inches wide of the left-hand post. Fabianski had it covered, mind.

33 min: Moyes is still sulking. Arms crossed tightly. Frown on. Thin lips.

31 min: On the touchline, David Moyes enters into deep philosophical discussion with the fourth official. You can’t blame him for wondering what the hell is going on. That was a ludicrous bit of refereeing.

29 min: Rice tries to launch an attack and is cynically tugged back by Gundogan. The referee waves play on. The move breaks down. When there’s eventually a break in play, Anthony Taylor opts not to book Gundogan. It’s a preposterous decision after the most brazen of fouls.

27 min: Yep, it’s a game to enjoy ... but not necessarily if you’re one of the managers. Pep Guardiola prowls the technical area with a worried frown.

25 min: Two simple flick-ons and Antonio is romping down the left! He nearly breaks clear into the box, but Garcia sticks to him like glue and sticks out a leg. A perfectly timed challenge that allows Ederson to come out and smother. City go straight up the other end and nearly equalise, Cancelo turning Coufal inside out down the left and curling to the far post, where Mahrez tries to guide home from a tight angle. Fabianksi claims. This is a great game now. It could easily have been 2-0 or 1-1 in a matter of seconds.

23 min: A stat to worry City fans from BT Sport: their heroes have lost the last six Premier League away matches in which they’ve fallen behind. Plenty of time yet to snap that run.

22 min: A free kick for City that’s effectively a corner on the right. Mahrez wedges it in. Ogbonna clears with ease.

20 min: A suggestion that the ball accidentally hit Soucek’s hand as he chased that ball down in the build-up. But the VAR isn’t of a mind to overturn that moment of brilliance.

GOAL! West Ham United 1-0 Manchester City (Antonio 18)

This week, they’re one up! Bowen drives down the right again and earns some more good field position. From the next phase, Soucek chases down a loose ball by the right-hand corner flag and cuts back for Coufal, who crosses. Antonio, his back to goal and hassled by Dias, swivels and creams a glorious overhead kick into the left-hand side of the net. Ederson had no chance!

West Ham United’s Michail Antonio eyes the ball as it heads in his direction before opening the scoring in fine style.
West Ham United’s Michail Antonio eyes the ball as it heads in his direction before opening the scoring in fine style. Photograph: Justin Tallis/Pool/Reuters
West Ham United’s Michail Antonio (centre) celebrates scoring his side’s first goal of the game with Jarrod Bowen.
Antonio (centre) celebrates his goal with Jarrod Bowen. Photograph: Justin Tallis/Pool/PA Images


16 min: Cancelo rolls a defence splitter down the left. Aguero races into the box and chips inside for Mahrez, who can’t keep his effort down. Goal kick, and the game remains scoreless. West Ham were three down by this point last weekend.

15 min: City waste the corner. They’re threatening to click into gear, though. Some very attractive football already.

14 min: City probe down the right and win another corner. It’s played back upfield. Gundogan, quarterbacking from deep, creams a wonderful diagonal pass to spring Dias into the box. Dias chests down and is about to shoot from close range when Balbuena blocks him out. Corner.

13 min: Mahrez, Gundogan and Aguero combine crisply down the middle, suddenly turning up the speed with some slick movement and pretty triangles. Gundogan reaches the edge of the box before slashing wildly wide left. Lovely move.

11 min: City have had 70 percent possession so far. Both teams will be happy enough, though, each having shown some promise in attack.

10 min: Now Bowen gets the other side of Cancelo down the right. He reaches the byline and cuts back, but there’s nobody in claret on the end of it. Moments earlier, Antonio nearly squeaked through a small gap on the left. A few things for City to ponder.

9 min: This is better from West Ham, with Bowen going on a tear down the right. Garcia just about keeps up with him, but it’s a throw to West Ham deep in City territory. Coufal flings it into the mixer; it’s easily cleared. But signs that Bowen has the beating of Garcia for pace. That was a brilliant power dribble.

Eric Garcia of Manchester City chases Jarrod Bowen of West Ham.
Eric Garcia of Manchester City chases Jarrod Bowen of West Ham. Photograph: Jed Leicester/BPI/Shutterstock


7 min: Bowen wins a free kick for West Ham out on the right. Cresswell swings it in. A brief game of head tennis, and West Ham quickly give up possession again.

6 min: City come at the hosts again. Mahrez slips Walker away down the right. Walker cuts back, intending to find Aguero. Not quite. But the loose ball falls to Cancelo, who tries an ambitious curler towards the top right from 30 yards. No.

5 min: Mahrez drifts in from the right and sends a tempting cross into the West Ham six-yard box. It’s just a wee bit too high for Sterling, and Balbuena is able to head clear. West Ham are struggling to retain possession.

3 min: From the set play, Gundogan slides a low cross in from the left. It’s easy pickings for Fabianski. A nice bright start by City. Pep’s unchanged team quickly finding their rhythm, just as planned.

2 min: Antonio plays a speculative first-time ball down the left and nearly releases Fornals into acres of space. For a second, City hearts are in mouths, but Ederson reads the situation and comes out to clear. Turns out the flag would have gone up for offside anyway. City counter, Sterling slipping Aguero clear down the inside-left channel. Aguero wins the first corner of the match.

The hosts get the ball rolling ... but only after everyone takes a knee. Black lives matter. No room for racism. This is the first time City have named an unchanged side in 172 matches. October 2017, half a world away.

No word from David Moyes, but no matter, because here come the teams! Pretty bubbles fill the air as West Ham take to the London Stadium. They’re in their famous claret and blue. City follow them, and they’re turned out in second-choice black. We’ll be off in a couple of minutes!

Hammers fans are pictured on a giant screen in the empty stadium as the players line up ahead of kick off.
Hammers fans are pictured on a giant screen in the empty stadium as the players line up ahead of kick off. Photograph: Justin Tallis/Pool/EPA


Pep Guardiola speaks to BT Sport. “We decide to continue with the same guys to get the rhythm as quickly as possible. We were better in the second half [against Porto] but in some games you need time. We cannot deny what a strong team we played. West Ham are in a good moment in terms of confidence, which in football is everything. Or almost everything! They also have talented players, always. The teams who play in Europe and international competition ... with the Covid situation, you have to adapt, it is what it is.”

West Ham reward the players who came back from three down at Spurs by naming the same XI. There’s no Said Benrahma yet; he’s not fully fit. But Sebastien Haller is on the bench.

Manchester City are unchanged too. They pick the same XI that won 3-1 against Porto. There’s some big news on the bench, though, and it’s good: Kevin De Bruyne is back.

The teams

West Ham United: Fabianski, Coufal, Balbuena, Ogbonna, Cresswell, Masuaku, Bowen, Soucek, Rice, Fornals, Antonio.
Subs: Yarmolenko, Lanzini, Noble, Haller, Diop, Fredericks, Randolph.

Manchester City: Ederson, Walker, Dias, Garcia, Joao Cancelo, Bernardo Silva, Rodri, Gundogan, Mahrez, Aguero, Sterling.
Subs: Stones, Zinchenko, Steffen, De Bruyne, Torres, Foden, Palmer.

Referee: Anthony Taylor (Cheshire).


If recent history is any guide whatsoever, this is only going to end one way. Since drawing 2-2 with Manchester City in January 2016, West Ham United have met the Citizens on nine occasions. They’ve lost every game, a sorry sequence that has them on the wrong end of an aggregate 30-4 scoreline.

But losing runs are there to be snapped, and West Ham have reason to believe this could be their day. They’ve put in some impressive performances so far this season: a 3-0 win at Leicester, a 4-0 rout of Wolves, and that absurd three-goal comeback at Spurs last weekend. They’re as high on life as they’ve been for quite some time.

City by contrast haven’t been at their best so far this season. They’ve been routed by Leicester, held by Leeds, and weren’t particularly impressive in edging past Arsenal last weekend. They’ll also be missing their star man in Kevin De Bruyne and the influential Fernandinho. However, they moved smoothly through the gears in the second half against Porto the other night, suggesting the old confidence is flooding back. Momentum is building, a return to top form surely imminent. No better time to meet their bunnies again.

It’s perfectly balanced, in other words ... and it’s on! Kick off is at 12.30pm.